Craving a sweet and chilly treat in the sunshine state? Look no further than Sarasota, where an abundance of heavenly ice cream options await you. From creamy classics to unique flavors that will tantalize your taste buds, this article is your ultimate guide to uncovering the best ice cream spots in Sarasota. Whether you’re a local searching for a new favorite or a visitor seeking a scoop of local flavor, get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the city’s vibrant ice cream scene.
Downtown Sarasota
Downtown Sarasota is a vibrant and bustling area that offers a variety of dining and entertainment options. When it comes to satisfying your ice cream cravings, you won’t be disappointed with the options available in this area. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or prefer more adventurous combinations, there is an ice cream spot in downtown Sarasota that will surely tickle your taste buds.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: The Milk Run
The Milk Run is a must-visit for ice cream enthusiasts in downtown Sarasota. This charming ice cream shop offers a wide selection of flavors, from traditional favorites to unique creations that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop or feel like indulging in a decadent sundae, The Milk Run has you covered. Their friendly staff are always ready to help you choose the perfect flavor combinations, making your ice cream experience even more enjoyable.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery
If you’re a fan of cupcakes and ice cream, then Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery is the perfect spot for you. This delightful establishment offers a delectable variety of both cupcakes and ice cream, all made with love and care. From their signature flavors to seasonal specials, you’ll find something to satisfy your sweet tooth at Smallcakes. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a wonderful place to enjoy a treat with friends and family.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Kilwins
Kilwins is a beloved ice cream destination in downtown Sarasota. This iconic ice cream parlor has been serving up delicious frozen treats for years, and their commitment to quality is evident in every spoonful. From their homemade waffle cones to their creamy, flavorful ice cream, Kilwins is a true delight for ice cream connoisseurs. Whether you prefer a classic scoop or want to try their famous Mackinac Island Fudge flavor, Kilwins is sure to leave you wanting more.
Best Ice Cream Spot 4: Big Olaf Creamery
Big Olaf Creamery is a local favorite for ice cream enthusiasts in downtown Sarasota. With its retro-style ice cream parlor and wide array of flavors, Big Olaf never fails to impress. From their rich and creamy homemade ice cream to their generous portion sizes, a visit to Big Olaf is always a treat. Be sure to try their signature flavor, Olaf’s Oreo, or indulge in a sundae piled high with your favorite toppings. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make Big Olaf a must-visit when exploring downtown Sarasota.
Siesta Key
Siesta Key is a beautiful barrier island known for its pristine white sand beaches and laid-back atmosphere. But did you know that it’s also home to some of the best ice cream spots in Sarasota? Whether you’re looking for a refreshing treat after a day at the beach or simply want to satisfy your sweet tooth, Siesta Key has you covered with its diverse range of ice cream options.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Orange Octopus
Orange Octopus is a hidden gem on Siesta Key that is sure to delight ice cream enthusiasts. This cozy and colorful ice cream parlor offers a wide range of flavors, from classic favorites to inventive creations. With its commitment to using high-quality ingredients and making everything in-house, Orange Octopus ensures that each scoop of ice cream is a true work of art. Don’t miss their homemade waffle cones, which add an extra touch of deliciousness to your ice cream experience.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
For a truly unique ice cream experience, head to Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream on Siesta Key. Using liquid nitrogen, this cutting-edge ice cream shop creates made-to-order frozen treats right in front of your eyes. The flash-freezing process ensures a smooth and creamy texture, and allows for endless customization options. Whether you prefer a classic flavor or want to create your own combination, Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream is sure to impress with its innovative approach to frozen desserts.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: The Ancient Olive
While primarily known for its premium olive oils and balsamic vinegars, The Ancient Olive on Siesta Key also offers a delectable selection of gourmet ice creams. Made with the finest ingredients and infused with unique flavors, these artisanal ice creams are a true delight for the taste buds. From their refreshing lemon olive oil sorbet to their indulgent dark chocolate balsamic ice cream, The Ancient Olive offers a sophisticated take on frozen treats. So, if you’re looking to elevate your ice cream experience, look no further than The Ancient Olive.
Best Ice Cream Spot 4: Ciao Gelato
Ciao Gelato is a charming gelato shop located on Siesta Key, offering a taste of Italy right in Florida. Step into Ciao Gelato and you’ll be transported to the streets of a quaint Italian town, with the irresistible aroma of freshly made gelato filling the air. Using traditional Italian techniques and imported ingredients, Ciao Gelato creates authentic gelato that is rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. From classics like pistachio and stracciatella to unique combinations like lavender honey and fig, every scoop at Ciao Gelato is a piece of Italy you won’t want to miss.
St. Armands Circle
St. Armands Circle is a captivating shopping and dining destination located on Lido Key, just a short drive from downtown Sarasota. With its picturesque setting, charming boutiques, and diverse range of restaurants, it’s no wonder that St. Armands Circle is a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike. And when it comes to ice cream, St. Armands Circle has some notable spots that are sure to leave you craving for more.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Kilwins
If you’re in St. Armands Circle and craving a delicious scoop of ice cream, head straight to Kilwins. This well-known ice cream parlor has been serving up sweet indulgences for years, and their St. Armands Circle location is no exception. With its welcoming atmosphere and irresistible aroma of freshly made waffle cones, Kilwins is a true delight for all ice cream enthusiasts. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique options like toasted coconut and turtle cheesecake, Kilwins has something for everyone.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Big Olaf Creamery
Big Olaf Creamery also has a presence in St. Armands Circle, and it’s easy to see why it continues to be a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With its retro-style ice cream parlor and friendly staff, Big Olaf creates an atmosphere that is both nostalgic and inviting. But it’s the ice cream itself that truly steals the show. Made with love and care, Big Olaf’s homemade ice cream is renowned for its creamy texture and indulgent flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop or want to try one of their specialty sundaes, Big Olaf is sure to leave you wanting more.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Ben & Jerry’s
Ben & Jerry’s needs no introduction. This beloved ice cream brand has been delighting taste buds around the world for decades, and their St. Armands Circle location is no exception. From their iconic flavors like Chunky Monkey and Cherry Garcia to their ever-changing lineup of limited-edition options, Ben & Jerry’s offers a little something for everyone. So, if you’re in the mood for a scoop (or two) of your favorite flavor, head to Ben & Jerry’s in St. Armands Circle and indulge in some ice cream goodness.
Gulf Gate
Gulf Gate is a vibrant neighborhood in Sarasota known for its diverse range of dining options and lively atmosphere. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Gulf Gate, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or prefer more unique combinations, Gulf Gate has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Local Chill
Local Chill is a hidden gem in Gulf Gate that is sure to please even the most discerning ice cream connoisseurs. This cozy and inviting ice cream shop offers a variety of flavors, all made with locally sourced ingredients. From their creamy classics to their rotating selection of seasonal specials, Local Chill offers a taste of Florida in every scoop. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect spot to enjoy a sweet treat with family and friends.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Shake Pit
If you’re in the mood for a milkshake that will rock your world, Shake Pit in Gulf Gate is the place to be. With its retro-style drive-thru and menu filled with indulgent shakes, Shake Pit is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Choose from classic flavors like chocolate and strawberry or opt for one of their specialty creations, such as the Cookie Monster or the Oreo Delight. No matter what you choose, you can expect a rich and creamy shake that will leave you craving for more.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Scoops on Siesta
Scoops on Siesta, located in the heart of Gulf Gate, is a delightful ice cream shop that offers a variety of flavors and fun toppings. Whether you prefer a classic scoop in a cone or want to create your own sundae masterpiece, Scoops on Siesta has you covered. With its cheerful decor and friendly staff, this ice cream parlor is a perfect spot to satisfy your sweet tooth and create lasting memories with loved ones. Don’t forget to try their homemade hot fudge, which adds the perfect finishing touch to any ice cream creation.
University Town Center
University Town Center is a vibrant area in Sarasota that is home to a variety of shops, restaurants, and entertainment venues. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in University Town Center, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re a fan of traditional ice cream or prefer the tangy goodness of frozen yogurt, University Town Center has a range of options to choose from.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Sweet Berries
Sweet Berries is a beloved ice cream spot in University Town Center that offers a wide selection of flavors and toppings. From their classic flavors like mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream to their unique creations like blueberry cheesecake and banana caramel crunch, Sweet Berries has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings. Plus, their generous portion sizes ensure that you’ll leave feeling satisfied and content.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Menchies Frozen Yogurt
For those who prefer the tangy goodness of frozen yogurt, Menchies Frozen Yogurt is a must-visit in University Town Center. This self-serve frozen yogurt shop offers a wide range of flavors and toppings, allowing you to create your own delicious masterpiece. Whether you prefer a tart flavor like original tart or a sweet flavor like chocolate chip cookie dough, Menchies has you covered. And with their rotating selection of seasonal flavors, there’s always something new to try.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Yogurtology
Yogurtology is another excellent option for frozen yogurt lovers in University Town Center. With its wide selection of flavors and extensive topping bar, Yogurtology allows you to create the perfect frozen yogurt treat to suit your taste. From classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like cake batter and red velvet, the possibilities are endless at Yogurtology. So, if you’re in the mood for a refreshing and customizable frozen treat, be sure to swing by Yogurtology in University Town Center.
Southgate
Southgate is a charming neighborhood in Sarasota that offers a mix of residential areas, shopping centers, and dining establishments. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Southgate, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop, a refreshing frozen yogurt, or a unique ice cream treat, Southgate has a range of options to choose from.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Culver’s
Culver’s is a popular fast-food chain known for its delicious frozen custard. With its Southgate location, locals and visitors alike can enjoy the creamy goodness of Culver’s frozen custard right in their own neighborhood. Made with the finest ingredients and available in a variety of flavors, Culver’s frozen custard is a delightful treat that is sure to please. Whether you prefer a simple vanilla cone or want to try one of their specialty sundaes, Culver’s has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: WineStyles Tasting Station
While primarily known for its selection of fine wines, WineStyles Tasting Station in Southgate also offers a selection of gourmet ice creams. Made with high-quality ingredients and available in a range of flavors, these artisanal ice creams are a true delight for the taste buds. From classics like chocolate and strawberry to unique options like salted caramel and lavender honey, WineStyles Tasting Station offers a refined take on frozen treats. So, if you’re in the mood for a sophisticated ice cream experience, be sure to check out WineStyles Tasting Station in Southgate.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Culver’s
Yes, Culver’s makes another appearance on our list, and for good reason. With its commitment to quality and delicious frozen custard, Culver’s continues to be a favorite among ice cream enthusiasts in Southgate. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic flavor or want to try one of their limited-time offerings, Culver’s has you covered. Their friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect spot to enjoy a sweet treat with family and friends.
Bradenton
Bradenton, located just a short drive north of Sarasota, is a charming city known for its scenic riverfront views and vibrant downtown area. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Bradenton, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop or want to try a unique flavor combination, Bradenton has a range of options to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Bruster’s Real Ice Cream
Bruster’s Real Ice Cream is a beloved ice cream shop in Bradenton that offers a wide variety of delicious flavors. With its commitment to churning out fresh ice cream using high-quality ingredients, Bruster’s has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. From their classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to their unique seasonal creations, Bruster’s is sure to leave you wanting more. Don’t miss their homemade waffle cones, which add an extra touch of deliciousness to your ice cream experience.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Big Olaf Creamery
Big Olaf Creamery also has a presence in Bradenton, bringing its beloved homemade ice cream to this charming city. With its retro-style ice cream parlor and generous portion sizes, Big Olaf Creamery continues to impress locals and tourists alike. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop or want to try one of their specialty sundaes, Big Olaf is sure to exceed your expectations. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect spot to indulge in some ice cream goodness.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Shake Station
Shake Station is a family-friendly ice cream parlor in Bradenton that offers a variety of frozen treats. From their flavorful milkshakes to their creamy soft-serve ice cream, Shake Station is a hit among locals of all ages. With its fun, nostalgic atmosphere and friendly staff, Shake Station is a perfect spot to satisfy your ice cream cravings and create lasting memories with loved ones. So, if you’re in Bradenton and looking for a sweet treat, be sure to swing by Shake Station.
Venice
Venice is a picturesque city located on the Gulf Coast of Florida, known for its beautiful beaches and charming downtown area. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Venice, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re in the mood for a scoop of refreshing sorbet, a creamy gelato, or a unique flavor combination, Venice has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Nokomis Groves
Nokomis Groves is a delightful ice cream spot in Venice that is sure to please both locals and visitors alike. This family-owned establishment offers a variety of ice cream flavors, all made with locally sourced ingredients. From their refreshing citrus flavors to their indulgent chocolate creations, Nokomis Groves has something for everyone. Don’t forget to try their homemade toppings, which add an extra layer of deliciousness to your ice cream.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Burgundy Square Cafe
Burgundy Square Cafe is a hidden gem in downtown Venice that offers a variety of delicious ice cream flavors. Featuring a cozy and inviting atmosphere, this charming cafe is the perfect spot to sit back, relax, and enjoy a sweet treat. From their classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to their creative combinations like lavender honey and sea salt caramel, Burgundy Square Cafe has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings. Be sure to try their homemade waffle cones, which add an extra touch of deliciousness to your ice cream experience.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Rita’s Italian Ice
Rita’s Italian Ice in Venice offers a refreshing twist on traditional ice cream. Known for their velvety-smooth Italian ice and creamy custard, Rita’s is a hit among locals and visitors alike. With its wide range of flavors and endless combination possibilities, Rita’s allows you to create a customized treat to suit your taste buds. From classic Italian ice flavors like cherry and lemon to their unique gelati creations, Rita’s is a perfect spot to cool off and satisfy your sweet tooth on a warm day in Venice.
Palmetto
Palmetto is a charming waterfront city located just across the Manatee River from Bradenton. With its scenic views and small-town charm, Palmetto offers a perfect setting for enjoying a delicious ice cream treat. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Palmetto, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop, a refreshing shake, or a unique flavor combination, Palmetto has something to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Pop’s Sunset Grill
Pop’s Sunset Grill is a beloved waterfront restaurant in Palmetto that offers more than just delicious seafood and stunning views. This hidden gem is also home to an ice cream parlor that serves up a variety of frozen treats. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop in a cone or want to try their famous banana split, Pop’s Sunset Grill has you covered. The relaxed and welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect spot to enjoy a sweet treat while taking in the beautiful sunset views.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Shake Station
Shake Station also makes an appearance in Palmetto, offering its delicious milkshakes and soft-serve ice cream to the residents and visitors of this charming city. With its retro-style decor and friendly staff, Shake Station creates a nostalgic atmosphere that is sure to transport you back in time. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic shake flavor or want to try one of their specialty creations, Shake Station is a perfect spot to satisfy your ice cream cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: The Clam Factory
While primarily known for its seafood, The Clam Factory in Palmetto also offers a variety of delightful ice cream flavors. With its waterfront location and laid-back atmosphere, this restaurant is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. After enjoying a delicious meal of fresh seafood, be sure to save room for dessert and try one of their ice cream treats. The Clam Factory combines the best of both worlds, allowing you to satisfy your seafood cravings and indulge in a sweet treat all in one place.
Lakewood Ranch
Lakewood Ranch is a master-planned community located just east of Sarasota, known for its immaculate neighborhoods and range of recreational activities. When it comes to finding the best ice cream spots in Lakewood Ranch, you won’t be disappointed. Whether you’re in the mood for a creamy custard, a refreshing frozen yogurt, or a delectable milkshake, Lakewood Ranch has a variety of options to satisfy your ice cream cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 1: Sweetberries Frozen Custard & Eatery
Sweetberries Frozen Custard & Eatery is a beloved ice cream spot in Lakewood Ranch that offers a delicious selection of frozen custard flavors. Made with real eggs and cream, their frozen custard is rich, creamy, and velvety-smooth. From their classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate to their creative twists like turtle and birthday cake, Sweetberries has something for every ice cream lover. Be sure to try their signature Concrete, a thick and smooth frozen custard blend with your choice of toppings mixed in.
Best Ice Cream Spot 2: Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers
Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers is a popular fast-food chain that offers a unique combination of savory burgers and delightful frozen custard. With its Lakewood Ranch location, locals and visitors have the opportunity to enjoy the best of both worlds. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop of frozen custard or want to indulge in one of their signature sundaes, Freddy’s has you covered. The friendly staff and retro-style atmosphere make it a perfect spot to satisfy your ice cream cravings.
Best Ice Cream Spot 3: Culver’s
Yes, Culver’s makes yet another appearance on our list, showcasing its popularity and commitment to quality across various Sarasota locations. With its Lakewood Ranch location, Culver’s continues to be a beloved ice cream destination for residents and visitors alike. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic flavor or want to try one of their limited-time offerings, Culver’s has you covered. From their creamy frozen custard to their indulgent concrete mixers, Culver’s offers a delightful treat that is sure to satisfy your ice cream cravings.
In conclusion, Sarasota and its surrounding areas are home to a plethora of incredible ice cream spots that are sure to satisfy even the most discerning taste buds. Whether you find yourself in downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, St. Armands Circle, Gulf Gate, University Town Center, Southgate, Bradenton, Venice, Palmetto, or Lakewood Ranch, you’re guaranteed to find a delicious frozen treat that will make your taste buds dance with joy. So pack up your appetite and explore the diverse array of ice cream shops that Sarasota has to offer. Your sweet tooth will thank you!