Looking to embark on a sweet adventure through the streets of Brooklyn? Look no further! “The Ultimate Guide to the Best Ice Cream in Brooklyn” is your one-stop resource for discovering the most delightful frozen treats this urban paradise has to offer. From traditional classics to innovative flavors, this guide will lead you to the hidden gems that will satisfy your ice cream cravings. So, grab a spoon and get ready to indulge in the creamy, delicious goodness that awaits you in Brooklyn’s vibrant ice cream scene.
Classic Ice Cream Shops
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory is a beloved classic ice cream shop located near the stunning Brooklyn Bridge. This wonderful establishment has been serving up creamy, homemade ice cream since 2001. They are known for their rich and indulgent flavors made with high-quality ingredients. From classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to unique creations like peaches and cream, there is something for everyone at Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory. Don’t forget to take a stroll along the waterfront with your cone and take in the breathtaking views of the city skyline.
Ample Hills Creamery
Ample Hills Creamery is a must-visit destination for ice cream enthusiasts in Brooklyn. This whimsical ice cream shop delights customers with its playful flavors and imaginative creations. From their famous “Salted Crack’d Caramel” to “The Munchies” – a combination of pretzels, potato chips, and M&Ms, Ample Hills offers a unique experience with every scoop. Not only is their ice cream delicious, but the shop itself is a feast for the eyes, with colorful decor and a friendly atmosphere. Make sure to try their ice cream sandwich made with freshly baked cookies for a truly decadent treat.
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream has gained a cult following for its rich and creamy artisanal dairy ice cream. They use only the finest ingredients, including hormone-free milk and cream, to create their delectable frozen treats. With flavors like “Honeycomb” and “Vegan Brownie Sundae,” Van Leeuwen has options for both dairy and non-dairy ice cream lovers. They also offer vegan ice cream made with cashew milk and other plant-based ingredients, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a scoop. Head to one of their various locations in Brooklyn to experience the true magic of Van Leeuwen Ice Cream.
Unique Flavors
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
If you’re looking for ice cream flavors that push the boundaries of creativity, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is the place to go. Their philosophy revolves around bold and unexpected combinations, resulting in flavors like “Miso Cherry,” “Olive Oil Plum,” and “Cornbread Sundae.” Each scoop is a unique adventure for your taste buds. Don’t be afraid to try something new and exciting at OddFellows.
Big Gay Ice Cream Shop
Big Gay Ice Cream Shop is not only known for its fun and inclusive atmosphere but also for its innovative and delightful flavor combinations. From the famous “Salty Pimp” made with vanilla soft serve, dulce de leche, and sea salt, to the playful “Rocky Roadhouse” with marshmallow swirls and chocolate-covered almonds, you’ll find flavors that are as bold as they are delicious. Head to Big Gay Ice Cream Shop for a memorable and joyful ice cream experience.
Davey’s Ice Cream
Davey’s Ice Cream is a hidden gem in Brooklyn that offers a unique twist on classic flavors. With their dedication to using locally sourced ingredients, every scoop is bursting with freshness and flavor. From the creamy “Strong Coffee” to the refreshing “Earl Grey,” Davey’s Ice Cream presents a delightful range of options that will satisfy any ice cream craving. Be sure to try their signature “Toasted Marshmallow” flavor for a truly nostalgic and comforting experience.
Vegan and Dairy-Free Options
Little Baby’s Ice Cream
Little Baby’s Ice Cream is known for its out-of-the-box thinking when it comes to vegan and dairy-free ice cream. Their offerings include innovative flavors like “Balsamic Banana,” “Everything Bagel,” and even “Pizza.” Despite the unconventional options, Little Baby’s Ice Cream creates indulgent and creamy frozen treats that are loved by vegans and non-vegans alike. With their commitment to using high-quality, plant-based ingredients, Little Baby’s Ice Cream proves that ice cream can be enjoyed by everyone.
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
As mentioned earlier, Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is not only famous for its dairy ice cream but also for its wide range of vegan options. Their vegan ice cream is made with a luscious cashew milk base and is available in flavors like “Salted Caramel,” “Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip,” and “Mint Chip.” Van Leeuwen’s dedication to offering delicious vegan ice cream allows those with dietary restrictions to indulge without compromise.
Alchemy Creamery
Alchemy Creamery stands out among the crowd with its entirely gluten-free, vegan, and dairy-free ice cream options. They craft their frozen treats using a blend of coconut milk, organic cane sugar, and other natural ingredients. Alchemy Creamery offers an impressive range of flavors, including classics like “Vanilla” and “Chocolate,” as well as unique creations like “Cardamom Rose” and “Matcha Green Tea.” Whether you have dietary restrictions or simply appreciate high-quality vegan ice cream, Alchemy Creamery is a fantastic choice.
Gelato Shops
L’Albero dei Gelati
L’Albero dei Gelati is a little slice of Italy tucked away in Brooklyn. This charming gelato shop offers an authentic taste of Italian gelato made with fresh and natural ingredients. The flavors are incredibly diverse and range from traditional options like “Stracciatella” and “Pistachio” to more unique choices like “Saffron” and “Rhubarb.” Step into L’Albero dei Gelati and be transported to the streets of Italy with every lick.
Il Laboratorio del Gelato
Il Laboratorio del Gelato is a gelato lover’s dream come true. With over 300 flavors in rotation, this shop offers an unparalleled variety of frozen delights. From fruity sorbets to rich and creamy gelatos, there is something for everyone here. Try the classic flavors like “Chocolate Hazelnut” and “Strawberry,” or venture into the realm of the unexpected with options like “Wasabi” or “Olive Oil.” Il Laboratorio del Gelato is a fantastic destination for those seeking a truly unique gelato experience.
Dolce Brooklyn
Dolce Brooklyn brings a taste of old-world Italian gelato to the streets of Brooklyn. With an emphasis on simplicity and quality, this cozy gelateria creates gelatos that are smooth, flavorful, and true to their Italian roots. Indulge in traditional flavors like “Fior di Latte” and “Pistachio,” which will transport you to the gelaterias of Italy. Each scoop at Dolce Brooklyn is like a small piece of gelato heaven.
Soft Serve
Mister Dips
Mister Dips is the ultimate destination for a classic soft-serve ice cream cone. Located in a retro airstream trailer within a park, this spot offers a nostalgic experience that is hard to beat. Their soft-serve is made with rich and creamy ingredients, resulting in a smooth and velvety texture. Whether you opt for a simple vanilla cone or decide to indulge in a “Dipped Cone” coated with chocolate, Mister Dips is a must-visit for soft-serve aficionados.
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream is known for its high-quality ingredients and expertly crafted ice cream, including their delectable soft-serve. With options like “Toasted Black Sesame” and “Green Tea Pistachio,” Morgenstern’s offers a range of unique flavors that will surprise and delight your taste buds. Pair your soft-serve with one of their house-made toppings to create the perfect personalized treat.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
OddFellows, previously mentioned for its unique flavors, also offers outstanding soft-serve options. Their soft-serve is made with the same dedication to quality and creativity as their traditional ice cream. Indulge in flavors like “Burnt Marshmallow,” “Matcha Green Tea,” or even a swirl of two different flavors. With their commitment to using the best ingredients and pushing the boundaries of flavor, OddFellows is a go-to spot for both traditional and soft-serve ice cream.
Frozen Yogurt
16 Handles
16 Handles is a popular frozen yogurt shop that allows customers to create their own personalized frozen treats. With a wide variety of flavors and an extensive selection of toppings, the possibilities are endless. From classic options like “Chocolate” and “Vanilla” to more unique flavors like “Taro” and “Cookies and Cream,” 16 Handles has something for every frozen yogurt lover. Load up your cup with your favorite flavors and toppings for a delicious and customizable dessert experience.
Pinkberry
Pinkberry has become an iconic frozen yogurt brand known for its smooth and tangy yogurt. With a focus on simple and high-quality ingredients, Pinkberry offers a refreshing range of flavors like “Original,” “Pomegranate,” and “Blood Orange.” Add your choice of toppings, from fresh fruit to crunchy granola, to create a perfectly balanced and satisfying dessert. Whether you enjoy it on its own or as a base for a customized treat, Pinkberry’s frozen yogurt is a classic favorite.
Yogurtland
Yogurtland is a self-serve frozen yogurt paradise with a wide array of flavors and toppings to choose from. Whether you prefer fruity sorbets or creamy classics, Yogurtland has you covered. Their flavor selection rotates regularly, offering a variety of options that cater to different palates. Mix and match flavors like “Strawberry Lemonade” and “Cookies and Cream,” then pile on your favorite toppings to create a customized frozen yogurt masterpiece.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Melt Bakery
Melt Bakery specializes in creating heavenly ice cream sandwiches using freshly baked cookies. Their unique combinations of flavors and textures make for an unforgettable treat. Try their classic “Lovelet” consisting of red velvet cookies sandwiching cream cheese ice cream, or go for the more adventurous “Munchies,” a combination of pretzel cookies with potato chip pretzel ice cream. Whether you opt for a sweet and salty creation or a classic pairing, Melt Bakery’s ice cream sandwiches are sure to satisfy your cravings.
Coolhaus
Coolhaus takes ice cream sandwiches to new heights with their inventive flavors and unique cookie options. Choose from a variety of ice cream bases, including classics like “Vanilla Bean” and more adventurous options like “Balsamic Fig and Mascarpone.” Then, select your cookie of choice, ranging from traditional chocolate chip to unexpected choices like “Ginger Molasses” or “Snickerdoodle.” The combination possibilities are endless at Coolhaus, ensuring that every ice cream sandwich is a personalized and delicious experience.
Ice & Vice
Ice & Vice is a dessert shop known for its innovative and boundary-pushing flavor combinations. Their ice cream sandwiches are no exception. Pair your choice of ice cream flavor, such as “Milk Money” or “Opium Den,” with a freshly baked brioche bun or a confetti cookie for a delightful and decadent experience. With their dedication to using high-quality ingredients and their commitment to pushing the boundaries of traditional desserts, Ice & Vice is the perfect spot for those seeking an ice cream sandwich adventure.
Specialty Dessert Spots
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain is a nostalgic gem that takes you back in time to the days of old-fashioned soda fountains. This charming establishment serves up classic ice cream sundaes, floats, and milkshakes that will transport you to a bygone era. Indulge in a classic hot fudge sundae or try one of their unique creations like the “Caribbean Odd Potion” with rum raisin ice cream and pineapple, or the “Brooklyn Blackout” with chocolate blackout cake and chocolate malted ice cream. Step into Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain for a truly nostalgic and unforgettable dessert experience.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a cozy and welcoming bakery known for its exceptional pies. While pies may be their specialty, they also offer a delightful addition to any ice cream lover’s list. Pair a slice of their delicious pie with a scoop of ice cream for the perfect marriage of flavors and textures. From classic favorites like apple and pecan to more unique options like salted caramel apple or black bottom oat, Four & Twenty Blackbirds offers a pie-and-ice-cream experience that is second to none.
Dun-well Doughnuts
Dun-well Doughnuts is a mecca for doughnut enthusiasts, but did you know they also offer ice cream? Their doughnut sundaes combine the best of both worlds, featuring a warm glazed doughnut topped with a scoop of your favorite ice cream and drizzled with delightful sauces. Indulge in flavors like “S’mores,” “Creme Brulee,” or “Cookies and Cream” for a truly decadent dessert experience. Whether you’re a doughnut lover or an ice cream aficionado, Dun-well Doughnuts has the perfect sweet treat for you.
Farm-to-Table Options
Blue Marble Ice Cream
Blue Marble Ice Cream is a pioneer in the farm-to-table movement, using only organic and sustainably sourced ingredients for its delicious frozen treats. Their commitment to quality and environmental consciousness shines through in every scoop. With flavors like “Earl Grey,” “Strawberry Shortcake,” and “Pumpkin,” Blue Marble Ice Cream offers a range of delightful options that are sure to please both your taste buds and your conscience. Treat yourself to a scoop and support a sustainable business in the process.
The Bent Spoon
The Bent Spoon is a small-batch ice cream shop that focuses on using local and seasonally available ingredients. With a constantly changing menu that features flavors like “Meyer Lemon Sour Cream” and “Sweet Jersey Corn,” The Bent Spoon offers unique and flavorful ice creams that reflect the diverse bounty of the region. They even offer vegan and dairy-free options made with coconut milk or almond milk. Visit The Bent Spoon for a taste of their handmade creations and support local farmers.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
OddFellows, previously mentioned for its unique flavors and soft serve, also deserves recognition as a farm-to-table ice cream shop. They source their ingredients from local farmers, allowing them to create flavors inspired by the season and to support sustainable practices. With their commitment to quality and community, OddFellows showcases the best Brooklyn has to offer in every scoop.
Hidden Gems
Malai Ice Cream
Malai Ice Cream, located in Brooklyn’s Cobble Hill neighborhood, is a hidden gem that combines traditional South Asian flavors with the craft of ice cream making. Their unique flavor offerings include “Masala Chai,” “Turmeric Ginger,” and “Orange Fennel.” Malai’s ice creams are made with a base of milk steeped with spices, resulting in a rich and aromatic experience. For those looking to venture beyond traditional ice cream flavors, Malai Ice Cream is a delightfully unexpected and delicious choice.
SkyIce
SkyIce is a Thai-inspired ice cream shop with a twist. Combining traditional Thai flavors with unconventional ingredients, they create an array of unique and mouthwatering treats. From classic Thai tea to exotic flavors like “Durian” and “Tamarind,” SkyIce offers a taste of Thailand in the heart of Brooklyn. Don’t miss their specialty ice cream rolls, a technique that originated in Thailand and adds an extra bit of flair to their already impressive creations.
Butter & Scotch
Butter & Scotch is a delightful dessert and cocktail bar that combines the best of both worlds. While primarily known for their delectable pies and creative cocktails, they also serve up incredible ice cream sundaes that are not to be missed. From their infamous “Boozy Birthday” sundae with birthday cake ice cream and bourbon butterscotch to their “Root Beer Float” with vanilla ice cream and craft root beer, Butter & Scotch offers indulgent and playful desserts that are perfect for any celebration.
With this comprehensive guide to the best ice cream in Brooklyn, you’ll be able to satisfy any ice cream craving or embark on an unforgettable dessert adventure. Whether you’re in the mood for classic flavors, unique creations, vegan options, gelato, soft serve, frozen yogurt, ice cream sandwiches, specialty desserts, farm-to-table treats, or hidden gems, Brooklyn has something to offer every ice cream lover. So, grab a spoon and embark on a sweet journey through the diverse and delicious world of Brooklyn’s ice cream scene.